Supersoft brown sugar muffins with tall, crunchy, bakery-like domes, dotted with bits of vanilla poached rhubarb and sweet strawberry.
Rhubarb: Either poached, as directed, or diced small straight from the fridge (or garden!). I like to chop it quite small, smaller than a penny. Frozen rhubarb is fine too, just be sure it doesn’t have too much ice stuck to it.
Strawberries: Fresh or frozen, but diced as well.
Brown sugar: Light or dark should be fine. Pack it into the cup if using cups for measuring!
All-purpose flour: If using cups, shake the flour over the measuring cup and level it with a butter-knife to ensure you aren’t over measuring.
Butter: Softened but not melty, this way it will beat nicely with the sugar. Ensure it’s unsalted and if it’s salted, halve the amount of salt in the recipe.
Eggs: Best to use them at room temperature, you can always pop them in a bowl of warm water right before making the batter.
Cinnamon: Use the higher amount if you like an unmistakable taste of warm cinnamon. This could also be left out if you don’t like it at all and replaced with something like cardamom.
Buttermilk: Buttermilk’s creaminess, tanginess and exact level of acidity is perfect for this recipe. You can substitute with kefir if you like (plain, vanilla or even strawberry) or use a thinned out yogurt (70% yogurt, 30% water, more if it’s greek).
This isn’t a necessary step, but I personally prefer it as it makes the rhubarb softer. If you are the kind of person who likes your apple pie crunchy from not-overly-soft apples, then you might not need to take this step. But, in addition to softening the touch vegetable, this will also get some lovely vanilla flavor in there.
To poach you’ll make a simple syrup, then cook the rhubarb in the syrup for just a couple of minutes. Then you’ll let it set, the stalks absorb the liquid as the mix cools. You can make this a day or two ahead of time. When it’s time to add the rhubarb to the muffin batter, remove them from the liquid and dice them.
The remaining liquid is a rhubarb simple syrup, you can use it in drinks – like this one!
To get those, you need the right recipe (we got that!); one built to have enough flour to hold structure but not too much the muffins will be dry.
Then, there are two steps I take with all my muffin recipes to get that perfect rise and bakery-style dome:
Yup! Straight down the middle, all of the ingredients will halve nicely.
Yup, store it in a container in the fridge with the liquid.
Anything really, this is a solid brown sugar muffin base and raspberries, strawberries and blueberries will work nicely here.
Share & tag me on instagram @buttermilkbysam